lol judges have ruled 100s or 1000s of ICE detentions in various states illegal by now. None of that has stopped ICE from doing what it's doing. This kind of optimism in the law seems naive today because there is no mechanism to actually enforce it. All federal agents have very substantial legal & civil immunity, heads of departments have immunity as well. The head of the legal system is Pam Bondi who isn't even prosecuting child rapists, or Donald Trump who is one.
Even after Kristi Noem ruined countless lives and was responsible for deaths of innocent people, the only consequence she faced is being demoted to some made up job where she still gets paid to do nothing - no fine, no jail, not even being out of work, no accountability, no justice. None of the ICE agents involved have faced any consequences besides a leave either, we don't even know most of their names. The justice system is not working.
People who don't follow the news like most of the tech community are living in some dreamland of a system or treating it as a purely mental battle of optimism/pessimism vs. actually seeing what is happening.
> judges have ruled 100s or 1000s of ICE detentions in various states illegal by now. None of that has stopped ICE from doing what it's doing.
This is a weird one because ICE has lost so many habeas cases, mostly by dropping them, only for the 8th circuit court of appeals (which covers Minnesota) to overturn that the other day:
So this is pretty weird now, legally, since a ton of lower courts have assumed things didn't work this way and the appeals courts are now saying they're wrong.
This is a case where a person who actually was illegally present is denied release on bond and the court sided with ICE. It does not address illegal detentions or deportations without hearings. There are countless other cases where people are detained despite providing evidence of legal status, of inhumane conditions in detention centers, of ICE directly ignoring court orders, of ICE agents on tape lying about people ramming their car and assaulting, detaining or killing them, of ICE releasing detainees without any of their possessions or IDs on the side of the road in freezing weather, and more.
> It does not address illegal detentions or deportations without hearings.
It certainly doesn't address all of ICE's legal issues, no, but it does say they don't need to give this guy a bond hearing:
> Accordingly, we find that the district court erred in holding that the Government could not detain Avila without bond under § 1225(b)(2)(A) and in granting habeas relief on that basis.
My understanding from talking to a criminal defense attorney who practices in MN about this is that this seems to give ICE broad powers to hold people without bond which many, many lower courts had rejected not wanting ICE to have such a broad power for all the reasons you mentioned.
They didn’t sell it no strings attached, they sold it with explicit restrictions in their contract with DoW and the DoW agreed to that contract. Their mistake was assuming they operate in a country where rule of law is respected, clearly not the case anymore given the 1000s of violations in the last year.
Contracts evolve, don't be naive. If you invent the Giga Missile and the government buys it for its war machine, and then you invent the God Missile right after, the government is going to come back again to renegotiate terms.
This is all just completely wrong. Anthropic explicitly stated in their usage use of their products is not permitted in mass-surveillance of American citizens and fully automated weapons, in the contract that DoW signed. Anthropic then asked DoW if these clauses were being adhered to after the US’ unlawful kidnapping of Maduro. DoW is now attempting to break the contract that they signed and threatening them because how dare a company tell the psycho dictators what to do.
Maduro is being prosecuted and there was a warrant out for his arrest. There is no magic soil exemption if you commit a crime against the United States and flee to another country.
What on earth does "Two such use cases have never been included in our contracts with the Department of War" mean? Did they specifically forbid it in the contract or was it literally just not included? Because I can tell you that if it's the latter that does not generally entitle them to add extra conditions to the sale ex post facto.
>threatening them because how dare a company tell the psycho dictators what to do.
Dude it's a private defense contractor leveraging its control over products it has already installed into classified systems to subvert chain of command and set military doctrine. That's not their prerogative. This isn't a "psycho dictator" thing.
They have always maintained an acceptable use policy forbidding these things. It was not controversial, because the Pentagon claims they have no interest in doing them in the first place, until a regime-aligned executive at Palantir decided to curry favor by provoking a conflict.
When we ask for regulation and oversight from the government, generally we mean regulation and oversight designed to help consumers or citizens and align the interests of institutions with that of the citizens. Yes the US trying to force Anthropic to let them use Claude in mass-surveillance and auto-kill robots is technically regulation, no its not good regulation. It seems to be designed to hurt the average citizen not help them. The oversight that might help here is say the courts or congress stepping in and facilitating a public discussion and legal review on the kind of surveillance the DOW intends to carry out. Is that so hard to understand without being spelled out?
The media organizations and people who pushed the pro-Israel narrative already understand all of this - it's not a failure, it was their intended goal.
I'm skeptical any public company is really going to have the strength to develop junior talent no matter how many experts say its important or what the long term consequences are. ShitCo A will slash headcount and see their stock go up 50%, investors & VCs at ShitCo B will ask why aren't we doing this and will soon follow. The same thing played out with all kinds of manufacturing industry jobs.
The track record in all industries for companies having well thought out plans to develop talent is pretty bad in the age of money. More likely they just fire the juniors, slowly lose seniors and pray for AGI to take over all coding. Maybe it does and they win, maybe it doesn't and they start panic hiring after 5 years.
I didn't know about the long history of racism involving Elon's companies. But it seems Tesla had a problem discriminating against black workers since at least 2015:
"including slurs, nooses, swastikas, and threats found on equipment, in bathrooms, elevators, and even on new vehicles. The EEOC also charged Tesla with retaliating against employees who complained"
and has come up repeatedly since then, involving many workers and in different locations and newer factories. They still have a few lawsuits open against them from workers, shareholders, federal & state agencies.
Look at the massive and growing wealth & power inequality today, an age of aristocrats, then look at these AI fucks bragging about how AI will eliminate all white collar jobs. Obviously all of the gains are going to go to capital. You can already see LLMs are making programmers much more productive but it's actually causing lower salaries and job losses - so who's capturing the value of that increased productivity? Not workers..
Meanwhile US government is overtly corrupt, criminal morons, they certainly don't care or have any sort of plan to distribute the gains from this technology evenly. Scott Bessent is saying with a smirk on his face that the tariff refunds will not go to consumers [1]. These people actively hate you and laugh at your powerlessness. Hating AI is the right response because the current political system ensures 10% of the benefits will accrue to most people and 90% to the elites, the power imbalance gets even more extreme and it will lead to techno-feudalism (as it has in the past).
> Obviously all of the gains are going to go to capital.
Right now sota models requires a lot of iron.
It's possible that this will always be the case. But its is not a certainty!
We've seen software improvements shave orders of magnitude of compute requirements before. This could totally happen here. Iron could easily become stranded assets.
But that said, models have already become commodities, well somewhat.
Is the value in running inference or applying it?
Today, we dare not use vibe coded libraries for mission critical things, HTML sanitization as an example.
But one day, who is to say the industry won't be disrupted by a vibe coded database with ~100% Oracle compatibility?
Made by a nerd in a garage.
Established code bases is a moat today. It might not be in 5 years.
Big tech won't be well positioned to take advantage, because trusting vibe coded crap is risky.
My point is mostly: the future is uncertain. Big established software companies might see their moat challenged by nerd in a garage running LLMs in the cloud.
What about the Adobe suite? AutoCAD? Office, etc.
(To be fair, it's possible that software never was the moat).
> To be fair, it's possible that software never was the moat
This is the answer to all of your questions. Network effect and brand recognition sell Oracle, Adobe, office etc. Alternatives to all of them already exist, with either feature parity or close enough for most people.
The existing brands keep going because big companies and institutions don't pay for products vibe coded by some guy in a garage, they buy products that have paid support that they know will continue to exist for years.
Windows solution to this is exclusive fullscreen, which bypasses the compositor.
You can try Gamescope [1] from Valve, that's what Steam Deck uses - i think its a compositor designed to minimize latency but support the few things games need. Some compositors like KDE Plasma KWin support a direct scanout mode which is the same idea as windows' exclusive fullscreen. You might need to look for support for something similar in niri.
Thanks, I have tried gamescope but it kills the performance of games for me. All games have a lot of stuttering when I use it. It also didn't reduce the input latency. Same hardware is liquid smooth on Windows.
It's interesting because the latency is only when pressing keys on the keyboard. Mouse movement and button press latency feels as good as Windows, I can't perceive any delay. I tried 3 keyboards, it's all the same. I'm also not running anything like keyd or anything that intercepts keys. It's a vanilla Arch Linux system on both of the systems I tested.
It is set to 2 seconds based on `cat /sys/module/usbcore/parameters/autosuspend` but the input latency only happens in games. Outside of games it's fine. Also in game, if I continue to press keys faster than waiting 2 seconds, it still lags.
That makes it unlikely it's related to this auto suspend, especially since it only appears to happen when I use my 4k monitor, but I did set it to 30s just to rule it out and it made no difference. I brought it back to 2s afterwards.
You don't need exclusive fullscreen on Windows to bypass the compositor. Fullscreen borderless windows also bypass the compositor. And in newer Windows versions the compositor can be bypassed even in regular windows using hardware overlays.
Windows's desktop compositor DWM is actually very advanced, and I don't believe any Linux desktop compositor is anywhere close. It's one of the things I miss when leaving Windows.
I think we should stop making excuses for shitty practices. I can understand why they might do it, i can also see there are much better ways to deal with this situation.
Even after Kristi Noem ruined countless lives and was responsible for deaths of innocent people, the only consequence she faced is being demoted to some made up job where she still gets paid to do nothing - no fine, no jail, not even being out of work, no accountability, no justice. None of the ICE agents involved have faced any consequences besides a leave either, we don't even know most of their names. The justice system is not working.
People who don't follow the news like most of the tech community are living in some dreamland of a system or treating it as a purely mental battle of optimism/pessimism vs. actually seeing what is happening.
reply