Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You mention Venezuela, but what about India? France, Sweden, Belgium, Canada, Finland, and Denmark are all arguably socialist -- certain much more so than the US.

Any economic system fails when practiced by corrupt or incompetent governments. There are many failed capitalist states, too.

Edit: if you want to talk about scaling, China and India are debatably doing well (or at least improving rapidly), and both countries have 1.3B people.

China had an interesting idea with special economic zones: let people opt out of socialism if they want to, but stay within the country and get basic protections.



None of those countries are communist. They have large social welfare states, and tax rates that might push 50%, but essentially rely on the free market for most economic decisionmaking.

In many ways China is closer to pure capitalism than most countries on the planet. The vestiges of "socialism" primarily live on in their authoritarian government, restrictive social policies, financial repression and massive state-owned-enterprises. China is slowly moving away from the latter two as their massive problems are uncovered.


I wasn't talking about communism.

> authoritarian government, restrictive social policies, financial repression and massive state-owned-enterprises

None of these are key tenets of socialism as the article formulates it.

As I've said elsewhere, historical socialism is not the socialism anyone is advocating. No one is suggesting Stalinism.


I don't know about a lot of other countries but India's economic boom started after liberalisation[1] in the 90s, before that India was far poorer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_liberalisation_in_Ind...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: