Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>we cannot expect that the law in your country is the only law exists.

I doubt federal law covers taxi regulations in any country, it's generally local by-law or equivalent. The regulations are going to be different in Paris than they are in Lyon.



In Brazil the federal law L12468 [1] regulates the taxi driver profession. The federal law L8078 [2], known as the Consumer Protection Code, protects (as the name says) the consumer in any transaction, be it products or services. The section 39 subsection 9 states that:

"Art. 39. É vedado ao fornecedor de produtos ou serviços, dentre outras práticas abusivas:

[...]

IX - recusar a venda de bens ou a prestação de serviços, diretamente a quem se disponha a adquiri-los mediante pronto pagamento, ressalvados os casos de intermediação regulados em leis especiais"

In a free translation:

"Art. 39. The supplier of products or services is prohibited, among other abusive practices:

[...]

IX - to refuse the sale of goods or the provision of services, directly to anyone who is willing to acquire them upon prompt payment, except in cases of intermediation regulated in special laws"

This is just an example of how the law structure can be so different between countries. Brazil as France are based on the civil law, instead of common law as in the United States.

I really don't know how is in France and I am not saying it is like Brazil. I'm just saying that with so many countries in the world doesn't make sense to expect the rest of the world to be like your home.

[1] http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_Ato2011-2014/2011/Lei/...

[2] http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/l8078.htm


I find it amusing that in the course of chiding me for allegedly assuming laws are the same in all countries you assumed I'm American (I'm not).

I'm a taxi driver speaking generally about the differences in our job vs. Uber drivers. I will now step back and let the software developers argue about things they know nothing about.


I know very little about it but it seems a pretty idiotic sector with strange rules in every village. In NL they will deliver 12 euro worth of food for free 25 km away. A 500 meter taxi ride will cost at least 10 euro. 100 euro for 50 km. I read stories about other places where prices are so low they cant realistically pay for the car.


Absolutely incorrect. It's not a rule at all.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: