Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From "how many people" to "what people" there is only a single step.

And it is very very very easy to take it.

That a congressperson makes this kind of question speaks volumes about him. Unbelievable.



I know I'll be downvoted for this, but fundamentally this definition[1] includes "and forcible suppression of opposition". In what way is this letter not the first step in this direction?

I'm no fan of the previous president. Really didn't like him. But this ... this attempt at shutting down of opposition communication, is the hallmark, the signature of nascent oppression. And a slide into fascism/socialism/etc.

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fascism


In what way /is/ this letter the first step in this direction?

> "But this ... this attempt at shutting down of opposition communication"

... is completely imaginary? A member of Congress writing a letter to Tyson Chicken asking what steps they took after the COVID incident of placing bets on how many workers would get infected, is not something you can reasonably turn into "this attempt at shutting down food production". It's not like these are secret backroom letters with threatening content released by whistleblowers to embarrass the senders, these letters were announced by official press release[1].

There is no attempt at shutting down of opposition communication in writing a letter that asks questions to which the media company can reply "we don't censor content". Do Anna Eshoo or Jerry McNerny have any unusual influence over funding or licensing (etc.) decisions for Cox, Alphabet, AT&T, Dish, than any other Congressperson, in a way that would make the letters carry more weight than their content suggests?

[1] https://eshoo.house.gov/media/press-releases/eshoo-mcnerney-...


Saying that you will be downvoted guarantees it.

You are right but it is best not to mention the beast, in my opinion.


Until we confront this, without fabricating fever swamp fiction to frighten captive tribal masses, we are going to be stuck in this dystopia. Teetering on the edge of {fasc,Democratic|National social}ism who all seek to control the narrative and suppress dissent.


"Gosh, that's only one step away from something worse" is true of literally everything anyone has ever done.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: