Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I fully agree with Youtube faking data. However, I reckon they are faking a bit too much. Many times I would see 2000 likes and the video having 1700 views (Viral videos that is).

I knew the view counter wasn't propagated but the likes were and I was like: "Damn this is Youtube, kinda disappointing..."

I guess if both were propagated at the same time I wouldn't mind.



I honestly don't understand why they simply don't use out of sync data. You could have nodes periodically send aggregates of likes & views, and then add those in to the total ever N heartbeats. Why bother fudging the in-between.


They're probably propagating the likes and views independently. Which still doesn't explain why they allow counter-intuitive gaps like that instead of fixing them up on the client-side in javascript.


Yeah, the view counter is a clear case where they've gone too far. People care about view counts and it seems like every other video I watch has people complaining in the comments about the view count being obviously wrong.


The only time I notice this is when the view counts freeze at 300-ish for a few hours. That's because they're checking if the views are legit or from a bot, IIRC.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: