Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The funny thing about Facebook is that it's got a perfectly good social network in there, I think the only one that exists. In the menu is "Feeds" which is what you want. It only shows friends and followed things. If they made that the default when you go to facebook.com I don't think I'd have any complaints feature-wise, though an ad-free option would be nice. It's a genuine social network.

Of course, then there's the question of who decides how and what is moderated, and the question of who can access your data, and Facebook definitely leaves a lot to be desired in that area just in terms of Meta not being a particularly trustworthy entity to have control of those decisions.

 help



Wow, I did not know about this Feeds page despite being a daily FB user for 20 years (yes, to the ridicule of most people, I know). Thanks for pointing this out. I wish this was the default homepage or at least a way to set it as default.

Each feed has a unique URL, so you can bookmark it in your browser. For people using Facebook via native mobile apps, my recommendation would be to stop and use a browser.

> Meta not being a particularly trustworthy entity

> For people using Facebook via native mobile apps, my recommendation would be to stop and use a browser

Related (2025): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44169115


Thankfully, since then, Chrome and all other major browsers now ask the user for permission before letting websites send requests to localhost or any local IP addresses. Obviously some users may click through that, but it prevents the behavior from being invisible to the user at least, and gives them a way to say no.

https://developer.chrome.com/blog/local-network-access

PS: I still recommend never installing Meta apps on your phone.

PPS: There are legitimate uses of this functionality, so as a web dev I'm happy the functionality wasn't silently blocked. This gives an opportunity to explain to the user why the permission is needed if the use is legitimate. Would be nice if it could be further scoped though.


Chrome added that _after_ sb discovered meta abusing it.

Yep, that's why I said since then

Annoyingly I can not get it to work on mobile (iOS Safari). Loading the url cause the page to refresh and take me to the main page.

Goes to show how much my 300 friends use Facebook, I had to scroll at least 3 pages before I found a post from my grandma in law about her dog, and that was all for the next few scrolls. Everything else was followed pages that I actually don't care about and ads.

> or at least a way to set it as default

Ctrl+D?


The only thing I used Facebook, is for marketplace and groups you can buy cheap stuff on there.

facebook does have an ads-free paid option: https://www.facebook.com/help/262038446684066/

in europe


I could be wrong but I think they were basically forced to add Feeds by regulation (out of Europe?)

For ages it was Top Stories vs Most Recent. Most Recent didn't even work, and of course it would always change you back to Top Stories

With all the potential of the internet, we got stuck with fucking Zuckerberg? We know what he thinks about people.


> I think the only one that exists

Wechat moments show you the things that your contacts post. There are theoretically ads too, but ever since they forcibly converted me to a US-based account I don't get ads because no one is interested in advertising to me.

It's too bad; I liked seeing the Chinese ads.

Comments on wechat follow the Maplestory system where you can see comments (on anyone's posts) from your own contacts, but not from other people.


WhatsApp too is my only social media, you can see the updates from your contacts

oMg thank you for pointing this out. I knew instagram had this as it’s top center. (X has to too). I didn’t know fb had it. So much better!

Wow, that Feeds page is great! Did not know.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: