Probably it is one. The domain record is fresh, so someone probably scooped it up.

Also the host is running under CPanel, which hardly seems like _why.

http://173.192.128.240

Here are other sites hosted on the same nameserver and IP: http://www.websitelooker.net/ns/ns1.certifiednutmilk.com

According to: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=773229 his domain expired in January.